Skip to content
MonSDR

The cargo

The simple question as a cold email hook

With the simple question hook, your cold email asks the prospect one question, tied to the signal you spotted, that they can answer in a line.

No link, nothing to read or book. It suits offers where you need to understand their situation before proposing anything, and it takes a question that actually teaches you something.

On this page
When to use it
When you have nothing to show yet, your offer depends on the prospect's situation, and a one-line answer is enough to tell whether there's something to talk about.
What MonSDR measures
Positive replies (no link, so no clicks)

Industries where it works well

The simple question is the lightest hook there is: a signal, a question, a signature. No link, no attachment, no slot to book. All the prospect has to do is reply, in one line if they like. It's also the hardest to write well, because everything rests on a single sentence.

What you're offering, and what it costs the prospect

You're offering nothing but a conversation. The cost to the prospect is tiny: a few seconds to read, a few words to answer. What holds them back is doubt rather than time: “why are they asking me this?” The signal clears that doubt before it forms, because it shows where your question comes from.

A good question, a bad question

A good question:

  • follows from the signal you mention (“your Google listing has no opening hours: is that on purpose?”);
  • can be answered without looking anything up or opening a file;
  • tells you what you need to know to decide whether there's something to discuss.

A bad question:

  • is rhetorical (“would you like more customers?”);
  • makes the prospect do your homework (“what are your three biggest priorities this year?”);
  • is a meeting request in disguise (“shall we talk on Friday?”).

What you need before using it: a signal that justifies the question, and a clear idea of what you'll do with each answer. If the reply is “yes, that's a real problem”, you have something to talk about. If it's “no, we've got it covered”, you've learnt something and lost nothing.

When the simple question works, and when to skip it

It works with small businesses where the person reading the email is the one who decides: local businesses, accounting firms, online shops run by their founders. It's also handy when you don't yet have an audit, a guide or a case study: it needs no preparation, just a signal.

Skip it when your offer is already clear and the prospect has everything they need to decide: a free audit or a trial gives them more to go on. Skip it too when the email is likely to pass through several hands before reaching the right person: a short question with no context doesn't survive being forwarded.

Three simple question emails

The highlighted phrase is the signal. There's no link, and that's deliberate.

Simple question, direct toneExample

Fenwick's opening hours on Google

Hi Joanne, Your bakery's Google listing doesn't show your opening hours. Is that deliberate, or has nobody had time to add them? Paul Henderson, Henderson Local

Three lines. The question can be answered with yes, no or one sentence.

Simple question, casual toneExample

Quick one about your shop's ads

Hi Becky, Quick question while I was on littleknit.example: I can't see any ad pixel on the shop, no Meta, Google or TikTok. Are you not running ads at the moment, or tracking sales another way? Cheers, Adam Price, Price Studio

Simple question, expert toneExample

Kershaw & Co's website and Google

Hi Richard, Looking at kershaw-co.example, I noticed several pages have no title for Google and the site has no sitemap. In practice, that gives Google fewer clues about what each page offers. Is anyone looking after the site at the moment, or has it stayed as it was since launch? Claire Holloway, Holloway Search

No link means no clicks. So the app measures replies, positive replies and meetings. Replies are sorted into “interested”, “later” and “no”, each with a suggested response you can edit. For this hook, don't go by the raw number of replies: a well-put question also gets you plenty of “no thanks”. What counts is positive replies.

To compare it with a hook that has a link, rank on positive replies or meetings, never on clicks, where it would score zero by design. The hook ranking is marked “early signal” while the gap isn't clear, with an estimate of the sends still needed to settle it, then “reliable” (a two-proportion test at the 5% level, or non-overlapping Wilson intervals, with at least 30 sends per group).

588

sends per hook to tell 2% from 5% positive replies

Calculation assumption: two-proportion test, 5% significance level, 80% power.

That figure comes from a calculation, not an observation: if one hook gets 2% positive replies and the other 5%, you need about 588 sends each to see it. The full working is in how many emails to compare two targets, and the six hooks are compared in six hooks for a cold email.

The two follow-ups go out while the prospect hasn't replied and stop as soon as they do. Keep the same question in the follow-ups, only shorter: switching to a new one each time makes it look as though you're hunting for any angle at all.

Why no link at all, not even to my website?

Because the only thing you're asking for is a reply. A link opens another door (click, read, compare) and the question turns into a pretext. Your signature is enough for the prospect to place you.

What do I do after a no?

The sequence stops by itself. Say thanks in one line, and if the prospect doesn't want to hear from you again, add them to the exclusion list.

How do I get from a reply to a meeting?

A reply filed under “interested” comes with a suggested response. That's where you propose the next step: a call, an audit or a trial, depending on what their answer told you.

Runway clear

Your first 5 prospects are on us.

Give us your website. Your agent shows you who it would contact, and what it would write to them.