Skip to content
MonSDR

The cargo

The free audit as a cold email hook

With the free audit hook, your cold email offers the prospect a short review of what you spotted on their website, online shop or Google listing, with what you would fix first.

It suits offers that solve a problem anyone can see from outside. You need a specific public signal for every prospect.

On this page
When to use it
When the problem you fix is visible from outside the business and you can show it for each prospect without asking them for any access.
What MonSDR measures
Clicks on the audit link, then visits to the audit page

Industries where it works well

A free audit is the most concrete thing you can put in a first email. You aren't asking for anything: you're showing the prospect what you noticed about their business and what you would change. They click, they read, and within two minutes they know whether you've understood their situation. It's also the least forgiving hook. Send the same audit to a hundred companies and the first line gives you away.

What you're offering, and what it costs the prospect

You're offering a short read of something public: a homepage that crawls on mobile, a shop with no email tool, a Google listing that's only half filled in. A handful of checked points, the ones that need work, and the order you'd tackle them in.

For the prospect, the cost is low: one click, a few minutes of reading, no call to book, no logins to hand over. The catch is that they can take what they need and never reply. So the audit should show the problem and why it matters, then leave the fixing to someone who knows how. Ideally you.

Without a signal you can see from outside, the audit rings hollow

Before you pick this hook, ask what you can observe about this prospect without them opening anything up to you. If the answer is vague, choose another hook. The signals that work for an audit are the ones you can read from outside:

  • Website: slow homepage on mobile, pages with no title for Google and no sitemap, no online booking (just a contact form), no chat or messaging.
  • Online shop: no email marketing tool detected, no newsletter sign-up form, no customer reviews on product pages, no ad pixel, an old theme that no longer gets updates.
  • Local business: incomplete Google listing, few reviews on it.

Company news (hiring, a funding round, a new managing director, a new office) is a good reason to write, but there's nothing to audit. For those signals, the straight-to-a-meeting hook or a case study works better. The same applies if your offer deals with things nobody can see from outside, like bookkeeping: your audit would be guesswork.

One more condition: your offer has to fix what the audit shows. A mobile speed audit signed by someone who sells copywriting doesn't add up, and the prospect will notice.

An audit page built for each prospect

When a target's signal can be read from outside (the website, online shop and local business families), MonSDR builds an audit page for each prospect. The link in the email goes to that page, made for them. It sorts what was looked at into three parts: points checked, points to fix and points already in place.

That last part matters more than you'd think. An audit that only finds faults reads like a sales pitch. One that also says “your product pages already have reviews” proves someone actually looked. In the email itself you mention one point only, the signal you spotted; the page carries the rest.

Pick a hook

To: Helen Ross · Meridian ConsultingExample

Hi Helen, your homepage takes 6.2 seconds to load on mobile. I've put together a free audit of your site. Shall I send it over?

Companies, people and numbers are made up for the example.

Three free audit emails

The highlighted phrase is the signal; the link goes to the prospect's own audit page.

Free audit, direct toneExample

Hartley & Doyle: what I noticed on your website

Hi Fiona, On hartley-doyle.example, there's no way to book a meeting online: visitors fill in a form and wait for a call back. I've written up what I checked, what's missing and what's already working: your audit If the booking point rings true, I can show you how I'd fix it in fifteen minutes. Tom Ashby, Ashby Digital

One observation, one link, one possible next step. Nothing else.

Free audit, warm toneExample

An idea for Wren & Wick's customers

Hi Grace, Your winter candles are lovely. While I was on wrenandwick.example, I also noticed there's no newsletter sign-up form, so a customer who isn't ready to buy leaves without giving you her email address. I've put together a page just for your shop, with what's already working and the two things I'd add: your audit Have a good day, Priya Shah, Fernlight Studio

Free audit, casual toneExample

Your Google listing, from the outside

Hi Declan, I was looking at garages in Cork on Google and came across yours. Your listing only has a handful of reviews, and every one of them is glowing. I jotted down what I'd change (it's a five-minute read): your audit Cheers, Niamh Byrne, Byrne Local

What MonSDR measures, and how to compare the audit

For this hook, the app tracks clicks on the audit link and visits to the audit page, then replies, positive replies and meetings. The two follow-ups only go out if the prospect hasn't replied, and the sequence stops as soon as they do. The first follow-up can pick up one point from the page; the second can suggest a quick chat.

To find out whether the audit beats another hook, run them side by side and compare them on the same measure in the hook ranking. Against a guide or a trial, clicks are comparable. Against a simple question, which has no link, rank on positive replies or meetings. The ranking stays an “early signal” while the gap isn't clear yet, with an estimate of how many more sends it needs, and turns “reliable” once it is: a two-proportion test at the 5% level, or non-overlapping Wilson intervals, with at least 30 sends per group.

If one hook gets 2% positive replies and the other 5%, you need about 588 sends per hook to see it; if one gets clicks from 10% of prospects and the other from 20%, 199 sends are enough. Those rates are assumptions for the calculation, not observed averages (see how many emails to compare two targets and six hooks for a cold email). The businesses where an audit has the most to work with: online stores and local businesses.

Why a link rather than a PDF attachment?

A link tells you who opened the audit and how often the page was visited; an attachment tells you nothing.

Can I send an audit to a target with no signal?

A target can have no signal, in which case the email leans on something from the prospect's website. But without a signal readable from outside there's no audit page for each prospect, and the audit loses what makes it credible. Go for the guide or the simple question instead.

Runway clear

Your first 5 prospects are on us.

Give us your website. Your agent shows you who it would contact, and what it would write to them.