The hook is what you offer in the first email in return for a little attention. There are six broad types, and people tend to pick theirs because it sounds clever or because they saw it land in their own inbox.
I'd start from a different question: what do you already have to hand? Every hook has a prerequisite (a real guide, a real case study, a calendar with short slots) and asks the prospect for a specific effort: read, try, reply, give up half an hour. A hook without its prerequisite falls flat, however good the email is.
Five of the six carry a tracked link, which gives you a click to measure before any reply arrives. The simple question doesn't. That matters when you compare targets against each other, as we'll see further down.
Free audit: show you've already looked
What it is. A short diagnosis, specific to the prospect, of what you spotted on their website, online store or Google profile, with what you'd change first.
When it works. When the problem is visible from outside and your offer fixes it directly: a freelance developer looking at a home page that's slow on mobile, an SEO agency looking at pages with no title for Google, an e-commerce consultant looking at a store with no customer reviews.
When to avoid it. When your signal is a company event (hiring, a funding round, a new managing director): there's nothing to audit. Also avoid the audit that reads like a charge sheet. The prospect may have built that site themselves.
What you need first. A signal that can be read from outside, and a clear view on what comes first. In MonSDR, website, online store and local business signals produce an audit page for each prospect, and that's where the link points.
What you measure. Visits to the audit page. A prospect who opens their audit without replying still tells you the topic struck a nerve.
Free audit, expert toneExample
Holloway Candles: your product pages have no reviews
Hi Ellie, Browsing holloway-candles.example, I noticed that none of your product pages show a single customer review, including the candles featured on your home page. I've put together a page with what I would set up first, and in what order: your audit Amy Clarke, Clarke Digital
The free audit page goes into more detail.
Guide: give something useful and ask for nothing
What it is. A document that's useful without you: a method, a checklist, templates. The prospect reads it whenever suits them.
When it works. When the decision takes time and the prospect cares about the topic without being ready to talk to a supplier. It pairs well with company news signals, where an audit isn't possible.
When to avoid it. When your guide is a brochure in disguise: the prospect spots it by page two and your credibility goes with it. Skip it too when the problem is urgent, because the prospect wants a fix, not reading material.
What you need first. A guide that already exists and stands up without your offer. If you're starting from nothing, keep it short: four or five pages on a single question your prospects keep asking.
What you measure. Clicks on the guide link. A guide also attracts the merely curious, so check positive replies before deciding it works.
Guide, warm toneExample
Three hires at once at Brightwell
Hi Tom, I saw that Brightwell is hiring two developers and its first salesperson. Three hires at once in a team of about fifteen: there's a fair chance you're the one reading the CVs in the evening. I've written a short guide to running those hires without an HR department: job descriptions, an interview scorecard, the first few weeks. It's yours: the guide All the best, Rachel Moore, Moore People Consulting
More on the guide page.
Case study: tell the story of a client who looks like the prospect
What it is. The story of a real client: where they started, what you did, the result in numbers, published with their consent.
When it works. When the prospect resembles the client in the story: same line of business, similar size, comparable problem. The closer the match, the shorter the email can be.
When to avoid it. When you don't have one, or when your only written-up client has nothing in common with the prospect. Never invent one. A prospect who asks to speak to that client should be able to.
What you need first. A client happy to be named (or anonymised), figures you can back up, and a page that reads in two minutes.
What you measure. Clicks on the case study, then positive replies.
Case study, direct toneExample
Ashdown Advisory: a firm that started in the same place
Hi Mark, On ashdown-advisory.example, several pages have no title for Google and there is no sitemap. I worked with a consultancy of a similar size to yours that started from exactly there. I've written up what we fixed, in what order, and what it changed for them: the case study Niall Byrne, Ricochet Search
See also the case study page.
Straight to a meeting: ask for a slot, with a reason
What it is. You ask straight away for a short call, with a link to your calendar.
When it works. When the prospect already buys this kind of service, when the signal points to an immediate need (a new office, a new managing director), and when your offer can be understood in one sentence.
When to avoid it. When nothing in the email justifies giving time to a stranger. It's the heaviest ask of the six, and without a precise signal it looks like every other meeting request in the inbox.
What you need first. An online calendar with short slots (15 or 20 minutes) and a concrete reason: what the prospect gets out of the call even if they never buy.
What you measure. Clicks on your calendar and meetings booked. Plenty of clicks and few meetings? Look at your booking page first (slots too long or too far out, a form that asks too much).
Straight to a meeting, casual toneExample
Your new office in Galway
Hi Julia, I saw that Delaney & Co is opening an office in Galway, congratulations. New address, new local clients: that's when the website and the Google profile need to keep up. If you fancy it, I'll show you in 20 minutes what I'd do in the first fortnight: my calendar Sean Murphy, Murphy Web
The straight to a meeting page covers this hook in full.
Pick a hook, a tone and a target: the tool drafts three variants for you to review.
See 5 prospects for my offerFree, no card needed
Simple question: start a conversation, no link
What it is. A single question that can be answered in one line. The aim is a reply; the sale can come later.
When it works. When your signal is a company event and there's nothing to show, when the answer helps you qualify the prospect (do they handle this in-house or not?), and when you don't yet have a guide or a case study.
When to avoid it. When the question is a sales pitch in disguise (“Would you like to double your revenue?”), or when it takes ten minutes of thought. A good question can be answered with yes or no plus a few words of context.
What you need first. A good question, nothing more. It's the cheapest hook to prepare.
What you measure. Replies and positive replies, since there's no link. The catch: comparing two targets with this hook takes more sends, because you wait for replies instead of clicks. The maths is in how many emails it takes to compare two targets.
Simple question, direct toneExample
A question about reporting at Arden Castings
Hi Paul, I read that you took over as managing director of Arden Castings in September. Quick question: the finance dashboard you inherited, are you keeping it as it is or planning to rebuild it? Claire Hughes, Hughes Finance Partners
See the simple question page.
Trial: let the prospect judge for themselves
What it is. The prospect tries what you sell without having to call you: trial access to your software, a sample, a first piece of work on the house (a translated page, a visual, a written email).
When it works. When your offer is easier to judge by using it than by reading about it, and the trial asks almost nothing of the prospect.
When to avoid it. When the trial needs an installation, a scoping call or access to the prospect's accounts. And when it costs you too much: if a sample takes you an hour and ten prospects ask for one in a week, that's ten hours of work. Do that sum before you launch.
What you need first. A trial page that works without you: a short sign-up, or a sample request form.
What you measure. Clicks on the trial link.
Trial, warm toneExample
A welcome email for Salt and Moon, on the house
Hi Isla, On salt-and-moon.example, I couldn't find any email marketing tool: no Klaviyo, Brevo or Mailchimp. So a customer who buys once never hears from you again. I'd like to write your welcome email for free, tailored to your shop. Ask for it here and you'll have it within three days: the trial Speak soon, Hannah Reid, Reid Copy
The trial page goes into more detail.
The six hooks side by side
Six hooks for a first email
| Hook | Effort to prepare | What you ask of the prospect | Signal measured |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free audit | Low if the audit page is built from the signal, high by hand | Open a page about their own business | Audit page visits |
| Guide | High once (writing it), close to nothing after | Read a document | Clicks on the guide |
| Case study | Medium: a willing client and figures you can check | Read a two-minute story | Clicks on the case study |
| Straight to a meeting | Low: an online calendar | Give up 15 to 30 minutes | Calendar clicks, meetings |
| Simple question | Very low: one good question | Reply in a line | Replies (no link) |
| Trial | Varies: nothing for software access, hours for a handmade sample | Try your offer | Clicks on the trial |
Testing one hook against another
Same rule as for targets: one variable at a time. Keep the target fixed, send it two hooks in the same week at the same volume, and compare. Change the target and the hook together and you won't know which one made the difference (the piece on why your ideal customer is probably wrong walks through the method).
In MonSDR, the hook generator starts from a type, a tone (direct, warm, expert, casual) and a target, and drafts three variants: you keep one, edit it or write your own. The hook ranking then compares clicks, positive replies or meetings, labelled early signal or reliable, and suggests testing a new hook or pausing one.
To: Helen Ross · Meridian ConsultingExample
Hi Helen, your homepage takes 6.2 seconds to load on mobile. I've put together a free audit of your site. Shall I send it over?







