Skip to content
MonSDR

Flight plans by industry

Prospecting online stores

Shopify developers, email marketers, paid ads freelancers and review tool vendors all sell to online stores; when prospecting them, you usually write to the founder or the ecommerce manager.

A store gives a lot away from the outside: its email tool, its newsletter sign-up, its product reviews, its ad pixels and the age of its theme. A free audit built on one of those signals is the hook to test first.

On this page

Public signals to look for

  • No email marketing tool detected
  • No newsletter sign-up form
  • No customer reviews on product pages
  • No ad pixel (Meta, Google, TikTok)
  • Old theme that no longer gets updates

Who sells to online stores, and who opens the email

Online stores spend money on three things: selling more to the customers they have, finding new ones, and running the shop without losing every evening to it. On the other side of the table you'll find Shopify, WooCommerce and PrestaShop freelancers who rebuild themes or speed sites up, email marketers who write welcome flows, Meta and Google Ads freelancers, product photographers, copywriters, and vendors of review or loyalty apps.

Who to contact follows the size of the store:

  • Founder-run stores, sometimes with one or two staff: the founder does everything from stock to Instagram. Write to them directly and keep it short.
  • Stores with a team: the ecommerce manager for anything on the site or the checkout, marketing for email and paid ads, finance for fulfilment or payments.

If you only work on one platform, filter by technology. A target can be limited to stores running on Shopify, PrestaShop, WooCommerce, Wix or Squarespace.

A store shows almost everything from the outside

The tools a store uses leave traces in the code of its pages, which makes ecommerce unusually easy to read before you write.

  • No email marketing tool detected (no Klaviyo, Brevo or Mailchimp). The obvious opening for an email marketer.
  • No newsletter sign-up form. The store keeps no address for visitors who don't buy on their first visit.
  • No customer reviews on product pages. For a review app vendor, or a freelancer who works on conversion.
  • No ad pixel (Meta, Google, TikTok). For a paid ads freelancer: without a pixel, an ad campaign struggles to connect its clicks to sales.
  • Old theme that no longer gets updates. For a developer offering a rebuild or a migration.

All of these can be read from outside, so each one gives you an audit page built for that store. Company signals (hiring, a funding round) don't produce one.

Splitting online stores into two targets

MonSDR asks for at least two campaigns, each with its own target. With online stores, four splits stay easy to read:

  • By technology: Shopify against WooCommerce, same signal, same hook.
  • By signal: stores with no email tool against stores with no reviews. You find out which problem founders recognise as theirs.
  • By size: founder-run stores against stores with an ecommerce manager.
  • By country: the UK against Ireland, both in English.

The target ranking stays an “early signal” until the gap is clear. For a sense of scale: if one target gets 2% positive replies and the other gets 5%, you need around 588 sends per target before the difference is reliable (a two-proportion test at a 5% risk level with 80% power). The full working is in how many emails it takes to compare two targets.

A free audit built on one signal

A store founder knows their sales figures. They don't always know what a visitor sees when they land on a product page from their phone. A free audit shows them, on one point they can check in two minutes. Audit page visits are tracked as well as replies. The free audit page explains how to put one together.

If you have a genuine result from a similar store, a case study is the second hook to run against it. App vendors can offer a trial instead.

Free audit, direct toneExample

What Wren & Bramble customers get after their first order

Hi Hannah, Looking through wrenandbramble.example, I couldn't find any email marketing tool: no Klaviyo, Brevo or Mailchimp. If that's right, someone who buys one of your linen cushions never hears from you again unless they come back on their own. I've written up what I found, with the first three emails I'd set up: your audit Sam Pritchard, Second Send

If that's right: detection can miss a tool wired in some other way. Check the prospect card before you approve it.

Case study, warm toneExample

Reviews on your stoneware mugs

Hi Siobhán, On kilnhouse.example, the product pages don't show any customer reviews, including the stoneware mugs on your homepage. Last year I worked with a small ceramics shop in exactly that spot and got its first reviews in without chasing customers three times. I've written up how it went: the case study Ollie Grant, Basket Studio

Only use this if the case study is real and the store in it is genuinely comparable.
Pick a hook

To: Helen Ross · Meridian ConsultingExample

Hi Helen, your homepage takes 6.2 seconds to load on mobile. I've put together a free audit of your site. Shall I send it over?

Companies, people and numbers are made up for the example.

Mistakes that lose you a store

  • Stating what you can't see. A store can send email through its platform's built-in tool, or track ad sales server-side, with nothing showing in the page code. Write “I couldn't find a tool”, never “you don't have one”.
  • Listing everything that's wrong. Six signals in one email read like a list of complaints. Keep the one that matches what you sell.
  • Writing in peak season. Through Black Friday and the run-up to Christmas, the founder is packing orders. An email asking for their time then gets buried.
  • Promising an outcome. “I'll double your sales”, written without seeing their numbers, reads like a template. Describe what you'd change, not a result you can't guarantee.
  • Forgetting the product. “Your store” proves nothing. Naming the linen cushions or the stoneware mugs shows you actually looked.

Two questions about prospecting online stores

I only work on Shopify. Should I leave other stores out?

Yes: filter the target by technology. Your two targets can then be Shopify stores with two different signals, or Shopify stores in two countries. Either way you're comparing one thing at a time.

What if the store fixes the signal before the email goes out?

It happens. The signal is spotted before sending, and a store can install a review app the same week. When a signal looks fragile, open the site before you approve the card, and drop the card if the signal no longer holds.

Runway clear

Your first 5 prospects are on us.

Give us your website. Your agent shows you who it would contact, and what it would write to them.

See 5 online stores to contact

Free, no card needed