Skip to content
MonSDR

Illustrative scenario

An SEO agency tests three targets and cuts the one it favoured

This SEO agency was certain B2B SaaS companies would be its best prospects, since their website is their shop window.

Who
Fernhill Search, a three-person SEO agency in Bristol (made up)
What they sell
Search engine optimisation for small businesses
The starting question
This SEO agency was certain B2B SaaS companies would be its best prospects, since their website is their shop window. It runs three targets side by side to find out whether they're really the ones who reply.

Companies, people and numbers are made up for the example.

  1. 01

    Week 2

    On the 600-credit plan, the agent contacts 138 prospects a week: three campaigns, one per target, 46 prospects each. For every company it spots a signal on the website (pages with no title for Google and no sitemap, or a homepage that's slow on mobile) and drafts an email offering a free audit, with an audit page built for that prospect. On Mondays the three partners work through the emails to review and adjust a few lines; sends go out from their three mailboxes, 30 a day per mailbox at most. After 92 sends per target, the SaaS companies are the ones clicking their audit most (11 clicks), yet only one positive reply comes from them, against 3 from the industrial SMEs. Those replies land in hot leads with a suggested answer, which the agency edits before sending.

    Decision

    Change nothing. The ranking is an early signal and the gap comes down to two replies: at 92 sends per target, it proves nothing.

    Campaigns compared · Positive replies

    Early signal · ~1,228 more sends
    Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff3 of 92 sends
    3.3%
    B2B SaaS companies · 10–49 staff1 of 92 sends
    1.1%
    Online stores · 1–9 staff1 of 92 sends
    1.1%

    Illustrative scenario

    Your agent recommendsNo winner yet between “Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff” and “B2B SaaS companies · 10–49 staff”: it needs about 1,228 more sends to call it. Keep your current volume.
  2. 02

    Week 4

    At 184 sends per target, the industrial SMEs pull ahead: 8 positive replies, against 3 for the online stores and 2 for the SaaS companies. The SaaS companies still click the audit more than anyone (21 clicks, against 17 and 13). The ranking is still an early signal: separating the industrial SMEs from the online stores needs about 860 more sends, and the gap with the SaaS companies isn't clear yet either.

    Decision

    Keep all three targets. The agency is starting to doubt the SaaS companies, but waits for the gap to become clear before cutting anything.

    Campaigns compared · Positive replies

    Early signal · ~864 more sends
    Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff8 of 184 sends
    4.3%
    Online stores · 1–9 staff3 of 184 sends
    1.6%
    B2B SaaS companies · 10–49 staff2 of 184 sends
    1.1%

    Illustrative scenario

    Your agent recommendsNo winner yet between “Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff” and “Online stores · 1–9 staff”: it needs about 864 more sends to call it. Keep your current volume.
  3. 03

    Week 6

    At 276 sends per target, the SaaS companies are still on 2 positive replies (0.7%), against 13 for the industrial SMEs (4.7%). This time the gap is clear: the app marks the SaaS companies as clearly behind. On clicks they're still in front (30, against 26 for the industrial SMEs). Between the industrial SMEs and the online stores (6 positive replies), the ranking is still an early signal: the gap has narrowed slightly, and the estimate goes back up to about 1,100 sends.

    Decision

    The agency pauses the SaaS campaign. The app also suggests doubling down on the industrial SMEs (from 46 to 92 prospects a week); the agency would rather split the 46 freed-up prospects between the two remaining targets, 69 each, to separate them sooner.

    Campaigns compared · Positive replies

    Early signal · ~1,068 more sends
    Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff13 of 276 sends
    4.7%
    Online stores · 1–9 staff6 of 276 sends
    2.2%
    B2B SaaS companies · 10–49 staff2 of 276 sends
    0.7%

    Illustrative scenario

    Your agent recommendsCut the “B2B SaaS companies · 10–49 staff” target: 0.7% positive replies, against 4.7% for “Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff”. The gap is clear over 552 sends.
  4. 04

    Week 9

    Three weeks later, each of the two remaining targets has 483 sends; the SaaS companies stay at 276, campaign paused. The industrial SMEs keep the lead: 22 positive replies (4.6%) and 8 meetings, against 11 positive replies (2.3%) and 4 meetings for the online stores. The ranking is still an early signal: it needs about 1,000 more sends, so seven or eight weeks at 138 prospects a week.

    Decision

    Keep 69 prospects a week on each of the two targets, and only cut the online stores if the gap becomes clear.

    Campaigns compared · Positive replies

    Early signal · ~1,030 more sends
    Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff22 of 483 sends
    4.6%
    Online stores · 1–9 staff11 of 483 sends
    2.3%
    B2B SaaS companies · 10–49 staff2 of 276 sends
    0.7%

    Illustrative scenario

    Your agent recommendsNo winner yet between “Industrial SMEs · 10–49 staff” and “Online stores · 1–9 staff”: it needs about 1,030 more sends to call it. Keep your current volume.

The takeaway

The target the agency favoured is the one that replied least: 2 positive replies from 276 sends, even though it led on clicks. It took six weeks for that gap to become clear, and nine weeks in, the two remaining targets still can't be separated. These are the example's numbers: they show how to read the ranking, not how your market will reply.

Why the gap with the SaaS companies was clear at 276 sends while the other two targets still can't be separated at 483: the wider the gap between two targets, the fewer sends it takes to see it. If one target replies at 2% and another at 5%, you need 588 sends per target to tell them apart; at 46 sends per target a week, that's about 13 weeks. The maths is in how many emails to compare two targets, and the hook used here in the free audit.

Runway clear

Your first 5 prospects are on us.

Give us your website. Your agent shows you who it would contact, and what it would write to them.

See 5 prospects for my agency

Free, no card needed