Where the order of magnitude comes from: if one hook gets 4% positive replies and the other 2%, you need about 1,141 sends per hook to tell them apart (two-proportion test, 5% risk, 80% power). At 23 sends per hook a week, that's almost a year. The maths is in how many emails to compare two targets; both hooks are covered in the simple question and the case study.
Illustrative scenario
A consultant compares two hooks on 46 sends a week
Two hooks to compare when reaching agencies that are hiring: is it better to send them a case study or ask them a single question?
- Who
- Niall Brennan, independent sales process consultant in Galway (made up)
- What they sell
- Setting up prospecting and sales follow-up for agencies with 10 to 49 staff
- The starting question
- Two hooks to compare when reaching agencies that are hiring: is it better to send them a case study or ask them a single question? And at 46 prospects a week, how long does it take to find out?
Companies, people and numbers are made up for the example.
- 01
Week 4
On the 200-credit plan, the agent contacts 46 prospects a week in a single campaign: agencies with 10 to 49 staff that are currently hiring. The two hooks take turns, 23 prospects each. The case study links to the story of an agency the consultant has worked with; the simple question asks, with no link, who chases sent quotes today. One sending address is enough: 46 new prospects plus their two follow-ups stay under 150 emails a week. After 92 sends per hook, the simple question has 2 positive replies and the case study 1 (plus 7 clicks on its link). The hook ranking is an early signal: with a one-reply gap, it would need about 4,100 more sends to call it, close to 90 weeks at this pace.
Decision
He dismisses it. A third hook would bring each one down to about 15 sends a week, and his signal (a job opening) can't be read from the prospect's website, so there would be no audit page to show.
Hooks compared · Positive replies
Early signal · ~4,076 more sendsSimple question2 of 92 sends2.2%Case study1 of 92 sends1.1%Illustrative scenario
Your agent recommendsTest the “Free audit” hook. Most clicks: prospects see what's wrong on their own site. It will join the rotation for all your targets. - 02
Week 8
At 184 sends per hook, the simple question has 6 positive replies and the case study 3. Meetings are level, 2 each. The consultant handles replies from hot leads, where each one arrives with a suggested answer that he rewrites in his own words. The ranking is still an early signal: the estimate drops to about 2,400 sends, a little over a year at 46 a week.
Decision
Change nothing. The case study has 14 clicks: people read it, without necessarily replying.
Hooks compared · Positive replies
Early signal · ~2,448 more sendsSimple question6 of 184 sends3.3%Case study3 of 184 sends1.6%Illustrative scenario
- 03
Week 12
At 276 sends per hook: 11 positive replies for the simple question (4%), 5 for the case study (1.8%). Meetings: 4 against 3. The ranking is still an early signal, with about 1,300 more sends to go, roughly 29 weeks.
Decision
Change nothing, neither the target nor the wording of either hook: editing one halfway through would reset the comparison.
Hooks compared · Positive replies
Early signal · ~1,316 more sendsSimple question11 of 276 sends4%Case study5 of 276 sends1.8%Illustrative scenario
- 04
Week 16
After sixteen weeks and 368 sends per hook: 16 positive replies for the simple question (4.3%), 7 for the case study (1.9%). The gap has held all the way, but the ranking is still an early signal: it needs about 850 more sends, 18 to 19 weeks at the current pace. On meetings it's 5 against 4, and the app rates the gap too small to separate the two hooks.
Decision
Keep both hooks. The simple question gets more positive replies but not more meetings, and nothing is proven yet: he waits for the ranking to turn reliable before putting everything on one of them.
Hooks compared · Positive replies
Early signal · ~852 more sendsSimple question16 of 368 sends4.3%Case study7 of 368 sends1.9%Illustrative scenario
The takeaway
At 46 prospects a week, two hooks with 4% and 2% positive replies take months to separate: after sixteen weeks, the ranking is still an early signal. The app doesn't name a winner before there is one; it says how many sends are missing, and that number falls for as long as the gap holds. The rates are the example's own, not a benchmark.
Runway clear
Your first 5 prospects are on us.
Give us your website. Your agent shows you who it would contact, and what it would write to them.
Free, no card needed





